Well, I can’t speak for Don, but I for one was just looking for the answer to this, and this thread was perfect. Kichu, Transpersonal, Mercime, thanks, you hit the issue spot on for me.
I wanted to simply take the comments off all pages (indefinitely) while keeping them available on blog posts.
In particular, thinking I was all saavy and smart, before finding this, I went into page.php and used the <!– to comment out the entire php tag – but it broke the pages.
I know that these different methods of commenting are used in slightly different ways, one for removing the instance of html (if I remember right) the other simply killing the php function. I don’t fully comprehend the differences in application of those, but anyway, I am a step closer to that, and my site is now working as intended.
Thank You!