Certain category page not "paging" correctly.

Hi everyone. I could really use your help.

If you look at like something this category page, you will see the page numbers at the bottom: https://www.mypersonalaccent.com/diy/

However, on this category page (that I changed the graphics on to match), it doesn’t “page”: https://www.mypersonalaccent.com/tasty-delights

If I take page 2 URL from the DIY category and modify it the Tasty Delights category, the other posts show up: https://www.mypersonalaccent.com/tasty-delights/?bib_page_offset=5

However,it still says only one page on the bottom even though there should be 2-3.

Can anyone help me figure out why it isn’t navigating/paging at the bottom?

Thank you!

[Moderator Note: No bumping. If it’s that urgent, consider hiring someone.]