ReviewPress only displays and averages first review

Hello,

I am using the reviewpress averages and form on two pages:
https://sonomaflatbreads.com/gluten-free/
https://sonomaflatbreads.com/certified-organic/

However, only the first review for each page is counted or displayed:
https://sonomaflatbreads.com/organic-reviews/
https://sonomaflatbreads.com/gluten-free-reviews/

In the admin, only the first review for each page displays the Page/Post Title in the Page/Post Title column–I’m guessing this is related.

I’ve tried turning off as many plugins as I can without messing up the way the site is designed… and I’ve updated everything I can.

Any help is much appreciated!