I have fully updated and brand new setup of Buddypress and BBPress in place and the plugin to thread the replies shows a big empty spot where the threads should be:
https://screencast.com/t/ooFdYQMn

What we were hoping to get was a thread feel like we have currently:
https://screencast.com/t/qKY1wAJcG

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hello! please don’t abandon this plugin because bbpress integrated threaded replies, this is not as good as your plugin because there isnt any pagination settings for threaded replies in the integrated version of bbpress! ??

whith 500+ threaded replies… it cant be shown on only one page this is not possible… dont know why it is like this!

So please update your plugin it was awesome but doesnt work anymore with the new version!

Thank you a lot for your hard work ??
Dorem

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Upgraded to WP 3.8 and now with this plugin enabled you can only view the first reply in any BBpress topic, the rest are all hidden. Anybody else experience this and/or have a fix?

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I just updated to WordPress 3.8 and the threaded discussions on my site can not be accessed from the Forums interface. I can see them in the Activities.

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

tried to use this plugin but it doesn’t seem to work as intended.

i have bbpress 2.4 & wordpress 3.6.

when I enable the lead-topic function in bbpress, the ‘admin links’ (edit, move, split, trash, spam & reply) disappear…

if I disable lead-topic, it comes back. also, only the reply in the ‘admin link’ works, the one that appears below the replies (which the plugin generates) doesn’t-using it just gives a normal reply, not a threaded one.

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

It shows the toolbar but you cannot type.

no JS errors or PHP errors…

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Not sure why this happened but I changed the code just in case someone else runs across it..

I changed the way the topic id is getting pulled instead of using the $bbp->current_topic_id I used the function that was populating the topic_id below.

Here are the diffs
https://collectivebias.com/temp/Screen%20Shot%202013-07-21%20at%206.56.30%20PM.png
vs new
https://collectivebias.com/temp/Screen%20Shot%202013-07-21%20at%206.56.52%20PM.png

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi Jennifer,

Sorry for bugging you, but have you had a chance to look at my Github pull request for your bbPress Threaded Replies plugin yet?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi, first let me say that I absolutely love this plugin; nested threads is something I’ve never really explored in my own forums before, so this is a refreshing change of pace from flat threads.

The issue I’m trying to figure out is simply that I want to move the Reply link from just below the individual post to being inside of the same div containing the post itself. I know the code for the Reply link is inside of ucc-btr-callbacks.php (around line 93, if what I’m referring to isn’t clear =\), and it would be easy enough to edit it to achieve what I want, but when/if the plugin is updated, my understanding is that this change would just be overwritten.

So is it possible to move this file to my theme so the theme’s specific copy of the file would be used, not the one in the plugin’s /includes/ folder? Barring that, is there another way I could go about doing this without needing to edit that specific file at all? I have been unable to find where exactly the reply’s html is being called to in the templates file, so it seems like this is the only real way to pull off what I’m trying to do.

Apologies if I’m not clear; I realize there’s a very good chance I’m rambling, so I’ll happily clarify if needed. And thanks in advance for any help on this.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I’m using your wonderful plugin for threaded replies. I am however finding that if i go in and change the order of the reply loop in bbpress that I’m getting multiple entries showing up. Is it possible to achieve the following:
List of replies that are ordered newest (at the top) to oldest and allow threaded comments as well.
Any help is appreciated.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I use the plugin “bbPress Topics for Posts” ( last version) is not compatible with this plugin.
With “Topics for Posts” plugin I can associate a wordpress post with a bbpress topic and it must show the replies to the topic under the post , instead at the comments.
“Topics for Posts” work fine when this plugin is disabled, but when is enable it show only the topic repeated egual for a number of times egual to the total number of replies.

Looking to the code of “Topics for Posts” I see this call
echo bbpress()->shortcodes->display_topic(array('id'=>$bbp_post_topics->topic_ID));
to show the topic replies that work correctly if this plugin is disabled.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi,

I installed this plugin but when I did the formatting buttons in the post box (i.e. buttons for “bold”, “italic” etc.) disappeared. So now users can only write plain text.

Anyon know why this happened, or how to fix it?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I have successfully activated the plugin. But, where exactly do I change my Forum settings to allow threaded replies?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi Jennifer,

Loving your plugin. I discovered one error: I’m using the default buddypress theme and latest versions of buddypress, wordpress and bbpress. When replying on a message in a forum with multiple pages, the redirect is always going to the second page.

Hope you can have a look at this. Thanks very much!
Kind regards,
Ramon

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I have made the translation file for Italian, how I can give to the plugins project?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I’ve run into a problem with threaded replies where the first reply to a topic is displayed twice on the topic page.

Further, when a user adds an unthreaded reply to the page, the user is routed to a page that displays only the reply; it’s the same for a threaded reply. For example a topic at:
localhost/wp/forums/topic/new-topic-for-forum-two/
Routes the user to here for a ‘normal’ reply:
localhost/wp/forums/reply/reply-to-new-topic-for-forum-two/page/2/#reply-2607
And to here for a threaded reply:
localhost/wp/forums/reply/reply-to-new-topic-for-forum-two/#reply-2613

The site permalinks are configured to the ‘Post name’ setting:
localhost/wp/sample-post/

After I disable threaded replies, the bbpress forum functions as expected. Any ideas as to a fix?

I’m using WP 3.5, Twenty Twelve theme v1.1, bbPress v2.2.3 and bbPress Threaded Replies 0.4.3. The site is pretty bare-bones right now, only bbpress, threaded replies and ReadyMade WordPress Importer

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

So far it seems to me like this plugin is compatible with WP-Markdown.
https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/wp-markdown/

You might be able to point to that as an alternative WYSIWYG editor.

On a related note, can’t you just disable the rich text editor for threaded replies? Seems like a harsh trade-off to have to disable it altogether.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I am so excited that the latest version of this is supposed to work with Buddypress but I have installed it and there are no options and it’s not working. Is there something I need to do extra that other than activate it?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

When I click the ‘Reply’ link, the focus does not go into the Reply text box so I still have to scroll up-down to find it.

Any ideas how to fix this?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hello all,

I was testing the threaded replies for bbPress on my buddypress site.

The issue we encountered was:
As soon as the user clicks on “Reply” link, the comments editor become unusable. I can no longer click on the comment box. TinyMCE editor just wouldn’t get focus at all.
The only way to add any comment was by switching from Visual to HTML mode.

I noticed this issue on IE9, Chrome.

Here is my setup:

WP: 3.4.2
Buddypress: 1.6.1
bbPress: 2.1.2
bbPress Threaded Replies: 0.4.1

Possible solution:
I would appreciate the plugin developer / other developers comments on whether the fix is correct…. Thanks!

After some googling (if thats even a verb) & digging through the code, here is what I found –

When the threaded reply plugin moves the comment box, the tinymce editor needs to be re-created. I have provided the reference for this theory in a link i came across later.

So adapting the theory from there –
Added the remove tinymce comment box instance in moveForm and also the cancel.onclick event.
Add it back as the last step in both moveForm and cancel.onclick event

All the changes were only in the js/bbpress-threaded-replies.js file:

You can access the update file from pastebin:
https://pastebin.com/susgyyAE

Make sure to use the IDs “bbp_reply_content” in the remove and re-create function.

Also there is a reference to ‘comment’ div id (t.I(‘comment’).focus();) – I had to change ‘comment’ to ‘bbp_reply_content’ since that appears to be the correct ID for the buddypress platform atleast?

There is an old there here which was my reference for the fix –
https://www.ads-software.com/support/topic/plugin-tinymcecomments-not-working-with-nested-comments-in-27

Hope this helps others out there having similar issue

Thanks,
Suresh

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I have several topics in the forum that have multiple pages. When I install and activate this plugin, the first page shows up, but the rest of the pages are gone.

I uninstalled the plugin, and I could again access pages 2 and 3. When I again activated the plugin, they disappeared.

Any idea what’s going on?
Thanks

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

I was not able to run this plugin on my development bbpress 2.1.2 website. It is running (I can see the js files in the source code, but from the outsider point of view no change). Do we have anyone here running it on the 2.1 bbpress site? Could you pls send a link to it just to see how it works? Now, I am running the 1.1 bbpress site with threaded posts plugin. Everything is fine, but anyway, sooner or later I would like to swich to the bbpress 2.X. Thanks a lot.

It seems that this plugin is not supported anymore. I do not understand why. The “threaded” functionality is really grat. But I can not migrate my current bbpress without having the threaded replies resolved. Sorry.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Is there any way to get bbPress Threaded Replies working in bbPress that is built-in in BuddyPress? It would be great!

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi

I am getting the following error:
Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/accnews/public_html/thecommunity/wp-content/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/bbpress-threaded-replies.php on line 128
I am running WP 3.4.1 with bbPress 2.1.2 using PHP 5.2.14
It is on my dev site, so nothing is broken in production, but any advice would be very helpful.

Thanks,

Brian

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

The plugin doesnt seem to display anything in the latest version of BB Press. Are you going to upgrade this plugin to make it compatible with the latest release?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi there. I’m running WordPress 3.4 with BuddyPress and a separate bbPress installation. I’ve copied the templates from the bbPress Threaded Replies plugin to my theme (Salutation) to enable threaded replies. The reply link is there and the nested replies are indenting as they should… but, the formatting has gone a bit haywire. From what I understand, the plugin looks for nested comment styles (which my theme has and uses) and applies these before defaulting to Twenty Eleven. This doesn’t appear to be happening… or have a I missed a step? Please can you indicate which templates or part thereof should be copied over. Thanks!

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi. I’m using custom WordPress and bbPress themes, and when I activate the plugin nothing happens. By nothing happens I mean that I don’t see an additional “reply” button or anything. Is there any additional code I need to add?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi Jennifer.

Thanks a lot.

I am using bbpress for topics-plugin and showing the replies and the reply form. This way bbpress handles wordpress comments. But the template isnt being used – I cant see the nesting and the reply-link.

Could you tell me how ?

Thanks,
Jacob

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Thanks for the plugin! It displays beautifully in the Twenty Eleven (1.3) theme, but not in BuddyPress Default 1.5.5 and it’s child themes like Frisco. The reply links are there, but there’s no indentation.
Any suggestions?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/

Hi Jennifer. Thanks for your work.

If I am using the “bbPress Topics for Posts” how can I enable the threaded style when viewing the replies as comments on the same page ? Is this a matter of templates ?

Will it be possible to switch the threaded style on or off per forum ? Can this be done with simple css ?

Thanks.

Jacob

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/bbpress-threaded-replies/