2 players on one page?

WordPress version: 3.6.1
Plugin version: pro version 2.3
Link to my site: https://www.jazzable.de/medien

I expected the plugin to do this: I wanted to have 2 players on one page with different playlists (in order to make clear which is trio and which is quartett demos)

Instead it did this: there were two players, but both had the same playlist which was not what i had in mind. and the playlist that was used appeard three times! Also I had a topic in between the two players which, but it moved behind the second player.

Here’s what I’ve tried so far:
I deaktivated all plugins – same problem
I switched to theme twenty thirteen – same problem

Is it possible at all to run two players on one page?

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/html5-jquery-audio-player/