@jhustead
If you have the premium version, we recommend you contact our support team directly — https://kb.yoast.com/kb/support/
@modio @dpitzer
That sounds like a plugin or theme conflict. Can you try and gather as much information for us as possible? Please perform the following:
1. Make sure the issue doesn’t persist when Yoast SEO for WordPress is disabled.
2. Check for conflicts. You can use the Health Check plugin in maintenance mode so it doesn’t affect your website traffic. Please deactivate all plugins and revert to a default theme like TwentySeventeen and then follow the steps to performing the conflict check.
3. Check for JavaScript errors with your console.
If you find any JavaScript errors related to Yoast SEO or if there is a conflict with a plugin or a theme, you can create a new GitHub issue for our developers. Please report the issue to a third party developer as well.
If you didn’t find any conflicts or errors, we think the issue is specific to your site. We’d need to investigate further but are unable to do so on these forums. You can purchase Yoast SEO Premium and receive our Premium email support and we can help you further.