AJAX Commenting/Inline Editing?

It would be quite possible to pull most of the code in P2 out and package it as a plugin.

I’m trying to do this manually. I’ve replaced my comments.php with the P2 comments.php, added the comment-form, made sure all the P2 JavaScript is loading correctly, added the P2 CSS classes, copied the P2 functions.php to my theme’s functions.php, yet the comments still don’t seem to load via AJAX. Is there a glaring mistake, or something I’m forgetting? (I’ve basically replaced my theme’s entire commenting framework with P2’s, but it still doesn’t work).

Some plugins for this kind of stuff:

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/ajaxd-wordpress/
https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/jquery-reply-to-comment/
https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/ajax-comment-posting/
https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/wp-ajax-edit-comments/
https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/ajax-comments/

Thanks for the suggestions, but I’ve honestly tried all the plugins (including Mike Smullin’s AJAX Comments 2.09 for $1). None seem to work with WordPress 2.8. AJAX Edit Comments works, but I’m concerned about posting comments via AJAX more than editing them.

If you get this figured out please let me know…I am looking for the same thing.

It would be great to separate the theme from the plugin! It’s a major pain to integrate themes and make IE work with it.

Yup. In fact it’s pretty shameful that AJAX comments aren’t included in the core/default themes.

There should be a standard method to do it.

Any news? I understand that the design is theme territory but clearly the core should support a standard method. P2 Ajax comments seem to be of beta quality these days.

What a knob.

Knob?