All Sidebars Show on All Pages

Hi

I have created 2 sidebars titled Consumer and Page Sidebar. For each sidebars, I have assigned specific pages for them to show on, and neither of them are set to show on the same page.

I have tried every combination I can imagine of Replace / Forced Replace / Shortcake / etc., with a page author assigned and without a page author assigned, and no matter what, both sidebars always show on every page.

I expect I am missing something painfully obvious, but after 9 hours of creating, deleting, recreating, playing with settings, I am nowhere with them.

A second issue is the sidebars don’t show on the home page.

Thanks

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]