background image was "confusing"

  • So I submitted a theme and got this in the rejection:

    REQUIRED: The background image from aside posts is confusing, please remove it.

    I gotta say guys, that’s a stupid thing to put “Required” on.

    Here’s the image
    That’s “BTW” common shorthand for “By The Way” which is a fitting association with something marked “Aside.”

    1) seriously, this is basis for rejection?
    2) How do I appeal this call?

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

  • This is best discussed via the theme’s Trac ticket or on the theme-review mailing list. But definitely not here.

    Please discuss in-ticket. The support forum won’t be helpful in this case.

    Thread Starter saintehlers

    (@saintehlers)

    Yes, Chip, your unnecessary update to a 10 hour old thread was very helpful. I already went in ticket (after I went to the mailing list and was yelled at there for being in the wrong place — perhaps WordPress moderators and helpers should coordinate to get the correct information out the first time).

    I did inform you that this was best discussed via the theme’s Trac ticket.

    Yes, Chip, your unnecessary update to a 10 hour old thread was very helpful.

    Perhaps not to you. But to later viewers of this thread, it will be helpful in preventing more diffusion of Review ticket-specific questions from Trac to the forums.

    Thread Starter saintehlers

    (@saintehlers)

    Yes, in the same sentence you mentioned the mailing list. note that the mailing list is what you linked to. You didn’t express that one was better, and the link implied that’s where I should go.

    Sorry but I didn’t have the url for your Trac ticket to hand.

Viewing 7 replies - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • The topic ‘background image was "confusing"’ is closed to new replies.