Blog entries not posting to correct page

The blog entries on my site are not posting to the blog page and I can not figure out why. Here are some details: each blog entry has a correct url (set in Settings –> Permalinks), but I can not get these entries to point to the blog page (https://peterandme.com/blog/). I must have changed something, but for the life of me I can not figure out what.

Site: https://www.peterandme.com

You will see the “recent posts” in the right hand navigation bar. But clicking “Footsteps (blog)” in the menu bar does not result in the blogs entries showing up.

Any help would be super appreciated.
Thank you, Peter