BuddyPress Members Profile Issue

Hello,

I seem to be having a problem with BuddyPress on my website. https://mybrighteststar.net/

Everything is working it seems, except for the member profile page. I have 2 members right now on the forum when you click on the ‘Members’ button. Me (admin) & my husband John.
If you click on my name to go to my profile, it will go to my profile. However, if you try to click on John’s name to view his profile, it will just redirect to my homepage. What am I doing wrong?

https://mybrighteststar.net/members-2/john/ does not work, but if I put in https://mybrighteststar.net/members-2/john/profile/ it shows his profile, so why is it not directing to this page from the start?