Can this style of donation be achieved

Hi there,

Yes, you could do something similar. To minimize the custom development work, instead of displaying the forms below when clicking, you could open the forms in a modal with our Button Mode shortcode:
https://givewp.com/documentation/core/shortcodes/give_form/

So you’d create two different forms, and add them to your page with our shortcode. One would support One-time donations, the other would support recurring donations. Here’s an example:

[give_form id="5500" display_style="button" continue_button_title="One-time"]

[give_form id="5574" display_style="button" continue_button_title="Monthly"]

Thanks!