Capture user submitted data (rate post) and aggregate

I have looked all over and found bits and pieces of what I want to do, wondering if there is an existing plugin to accomplish this goal:

I’d like to capture user-submitted data, append it to their user record, and display it.

example- post A is displayed. In the corner there is a dropdown that says rate it. A user that’s logged in can then pick a number from 1-10 in the drop down and submit. That entry is recorded, and when they read that post going forward it displays their rating.

In addition, I’d like to aggregate that post rating and display that.

I have seen a few rating plugins, but none that seem overly reliable. The choice of using a dropdown is if someone wants to rate from their phone.

Please let me know if this makes sense, any more clarity I can provide, and know that any assistance will be greatly appreciated.