Comments not showing up with AJAX but “load with page” works

My comments are no longer showing up with the setting “Initiate AJAX loading after page.” During my troubleshooting, I noticed they DO show up when I “load with page.” When I use the “Display [View Comments] button” they do not load when I click the button.

https://jefffinley.org/simian-line-palmistry/

Another thing to note is I’ve tried disabling all other plugins and also switching to the default theme, tried different browsers, used my phone, etc. The comments were just not displaying (despite showing the number of comments). The only way I can get them to display is by having them load with the page, but this slows down load time on posts with a lot of comments.

Also FWIW, when comments were displaying using “load with page” – the sorting functions for most voted or new/oldest weren’t working either.

I’ve disabled WP-Discuz and all the comments appear with the default comments.

Is there something I’m missing?

• This topic was modified 3 years, 7 months ago by starseedjeff.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]