Dropdown emails not working

In the form section of the plugin I’ve got this code:

<label> Subject (required)
[select* dropdown your-recipient “Sales Questions|[email protected]”
“Shipping|[email protected]”
“Product Questions|[email protected]”
“Other|[email protected]”]</label>

The “mail” section has a different email address: [email protected]. All of the email, no matter the drop down selected, goes to [email protected].

Can anyone steer me in the correct direction?

Thanks in advance.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]