I have only 2 warnings with server-scanner, but i think that has nothing to do with my problem.
The error I am receiving on browser console:
Failed to load resource: the server responded with a status of 500 (Internal Server Error)
https://mywebsite.com/wp-content/plugins/s2member/s2member-o.php?ws_plugin__s2member_css=1&qcABC=1&ver=151218-3402031376
Server-Scanner output:
Notice[NOTICE] WordPress Memory Limit:
Although NOT required, s2Member recommends that you raise your WordPress memory limit (please set: WP_MEMORY_LIMIT in /wp-config.php), to at least 64M (i.e. 64 megabytes). Please see: this how-to article. Or consult with your web hosting company about this message. Your current memory limit allows only: 40M
Notice[NOTICE] WordPress DB Charset:
Although NOT required, s2Member recommends that your WordPress installation be configured to operate with a UTF-8 database charset (please set: DB_CHARSET in /wp-config.php). Please see this article for further details. Or consult with your web hosting company about this message. Your current DB charset is set to: utf8mb4