Expires Headers and Browser Caching not working…

I don’t believe I’ve always had this problem, but as of late it appears the expires headers are no longer active on images and some other resources on my website. It also appears I have a 1 day expiration set for many of my sites resources. Neither of these should be the case considering my settings in W3 Total Cache.

This is the source of my concerns, the results under Leverage Cache Browsing and Add Expires Headers under YSlow.
https://gtmetrix.com/reports/allurexpressions.com/zUv3HAoX

Just a week ago before updating the plugin my scores were much better: https://gtmetrix.com/reports/allurexpressions.com/V9Bnzx0B

I’m at a lost for what the issue could be, I’ve just gotten everything back working under W3 Total Cache 0.9.2.5. I don’t plan on upgrading until all other issues have been solved, but this seems unrelated to the updates I would think. I’m not exactly sure how to post images here but I do have everything selected under Browser Cache, Expires header lifetime set to “31536000”, and Cache with max-age for Cache control policy.

Any advice anyone?

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/w3-total-cache/