Hi Sarah,
Thank for digging into it,
I am new to WordPress, so I do not really know the impacts of that decision. In my case, the reason why I do not have any Page Not Found error is because I have an author.php page in my theme. This page does not display the list of posts, but instead the detailed contact info of the author. I tested it and you are right, when I remove the author.php page out of my theme, I have a Page Not Found error.
I guess that the default behaviour of WordPress is to display 1) the list of post of the author OR 2) a page saying that nothing is found. However, when overriding the default behaviour (by creating the author.php page), we can have an author page even though the author does not have any post.
There is a “Link to Author Page” option in the plugin. Would that make sens to have the following ?
1) Link to Author Page -> select field with three options:
– Never
– Only if author posts are found
– Always
2) Open in separate window -> checkbox
The drawback I can see when considering post numbers is that it excludes all websites (used in Research for example) that do not use posts at all. For example, for a Research laboratory website, pages are used for, e.g., showing the different Research axes, the list of publications, but also for displaying the list of members. We do not expect the group members to be active “posters”, but list of members should be constantly updated and provide access to updated information of a member.
Thanks again for your reactive support,
Nicolas