Forcing Shipping Options for Products

Hi there,

I have a Woocommerce store that I am have set up but am running into problems with the shipping when there are multiple items in the cart.

So and exapmle of what I am facing is this – I have 2 items, and here is what I would like to do
Item X – A. with $10 flat rate shipping/item
Item Y – with 2 shipping options – B. $5/item for USPS regular and C. Customer pick up for free (I created it here because I did not want to offer the oick up option for all products)

I used the Advanced Flat Rate shipping plugin (free) to create the 3 shipping methods and assigned the relevant ones to Items A and B respectively. When I each only one item to the cart, everything works great. But when I add both items to the cart I have a problem. I see the 3 options above for shipping – but then if the buyer decides to pick the lowest option C, that gets applied to all 3 items. So now the cost of shipping is free across all items.

Is there a way to force options for specific products – either through the standard Flat Rate shipping that comes with Woocommerce, the advanced Flat rate plugin, or is there another plugin that I can get? Any help is much appreciated. Thanks!