@djlo you are confused about something
it shows the “From Name” as my site name
all you see is a bunch of emails with the website name instead of the person
These statements agree with this statement :
Of course, the sender is set up as myself
And contradict with this statement :
I’m trying to figure out if the “Reply to” name can be the person filling the form instead of my site’s name.
So to clarify:
- It is the From field that is used for your list of emails in your inbox
- It is the Reply-To field that is used for replying
when I didn’t have to use SMTP to send emails it showed up just fine with the name and the email of the person sending the form
This probably means that WP SMTP Mail is overriding the value of the from field sent by Gravity Forms. There are other SMTP plugins that have the feature you want, keeping the from field as Gravity Forms sent it.
Gravity forms allow you to set up just email as Reply to, not name in front of that field
If you can fix the From field, you don’t even need the Reply-to field. But, assuming Gravity works the same way Contact Form 7, this is simple.
Change the reply-to email to be :
Reply-to: [visitor-name] <[visitor-email]>
Note the angle brackets.