Home page showing wrong menus

I am using photocrati at dinamariaphotography.com. On all other pages, except home, my menus are showing up correctly. I have my theme locations (under Appearance > Menus) set to main and main and have my custom menu named “main”. I did see that somehow I have to home pages listed in the left pane under Pages (home:home & home). I tried both, but neither fixed the problem. I tried deleting my custom menu and re-creating, but that also did not fix the problem. I added the plugin Exclude Pages but that also did not help. I tried deleting pages (the client page has been deleted) but it still show up. I deleted cache within WordPress and via the browser. I tried in both firefox and chrome. Please help, because the pages no longer exist or have been moved to sub-menus, I am getting page not found on my home page, which of course is the first page my clients would see. Thank you.