Hi there,
I guess we’ll be covering a thing or two here, so bare with me.
The original post of this review, about the Pro version failing them as well as the free one are legitimate. When you choose to upsell your products via the free plugins on www.ads-software.com you have to accept that this is how people will view the plugin (as part of your free one), and the reviews about their experience are just as valid as any other review.
Next point!
Starting to bring up legal terms is just silly. I’m sorry that you felt hurt by the review, but the term “scam” is widely used to describe a feeling of feeling fooled (I Am Not A Lawyer), which coincides with the reviewers feelings after discovering they need to pay for more and more things to get the features they thought would be included in a premium version, and is how I would read it in this context.
We do have a “Code of Conduct” as you called it (we refer it as the Forum Welcome Page, it’s not a code of conduct, that’s something completely different, but rather a set of guidelines to follow when posting).
Now, let’s move on, because we can certainly make this better.
@mozalan
Could you, instead of using loud words (uppercase words are shouty), inform the plugin author of what theme and plugins you were using that the conflict existed on so that they could look into what was causing it and perhaps fix the problems?
You did mention that you had requested a refund, I’m glad to hear that you took the appropriate steps when you were unhappy with the premium product and I hope the two of you can sort that bit out in private as money talk really isn’t for these forums ??