Need help with shipping cost setting, totally confused~~~

My logic is:
1: Free shipping for all order over $50
2: Free shipping for some special product (even it’s under $50)
3: Shipping cost $5 for other order under $50

Here is my shipping setting:
1: Add shipping zone “USA”
2: Add shipping class “SPECIAL” for the special product
3: Add FREE SHIPPING method in USA zone, triggered when order amount over $50…
4: Add FLAT SHIPPING method in USA zone
4.1) cost is: 0
4.2) “SPECIAL” shipping class cost: 0
4.3) No shipping class cost: $5

and here is the problem:
1: when the product is SPECIAL class, it works great!
2: when other order is under $50, it works great!
3: when order is over $50, it works, BUT:
there a 2 options available on the checkout page, 1 is Free Shipping cost 0, 1 is Flat Shipping cost $5

So my question is:
How to remove the “Flat Shipping cost $5” when order is over $50, and let it just FREE SHIPPING available????

• This topic was modified 6 years, 7 months ago by moonswamp.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]