NoCaptcha Broken on All Sites

I use this plugin on all of my domains, today I realized while troubleshooting one that every time I was asked to verify I get the image widget asking me to verify 3 images.

If I’m reading correctly, that should only happen with outdated browsers or incompatible sites.

I deactivated all plugins but this one and I’m still getting the error. It is on all of my domains. I tried doing a clean install on a new domain with only this plugin and I’m still getting the image verification. What am I doing wrong here?

I tried creating a new recaptcha site with new keys as well and it’s still not working.

stancewars.com/happenstanceevents/wordpress/

https://www.ads-software.com/plugins/wp-recaptcha-integration/