Not accepting passwords

I installed it and put in 5 different passwords in your plugin’s area (new password per line)

Visibility: Password protected
 - Public
 x Password protected
Password:
111AAA
Multiple passwords:
PASSWORD1
PASSWORD2
PASSWORD3
PASSWORD4
PASSWORD5

I then applied changes, and saved out. I tried it, but it would only accept the 111AAA password, not the others.
(by the way, these aren’t the actual passwords)
So, I figured that I must need to not have a Password in that spot, so I did this:

Visibility: Password protected
 - Public
 x Password protected
Password:

Multiple passwords:
PASSWORD1
PASSWORD2
PASSWORD3
PASSWORD4
PASSWORD5

Then I hit apply and saved out. Upon save, it changed the page to Public.
Am I doing anything wrong?

Here is the check boxes on the settings page:

X Administrators does not need the password anymore.
_ Posts authors does not need the password anymore.
_ Logged members does not need the password anymore.
_ Check me if you do not want that...

Thank you so much ??

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/baw-multiple-pass-for-protected-pages/