Not Newest Related Posts Showing

Each of the team pages we have on the website use the crp shortcode to display related news. I cannot figure out why the listed 3 related posts are not the most recent items.

Here is the page with crp shortcode:
https://www.ncwsa.com/teams/michiganstateuniversity/

Here is the list of posts with matching tag:
https://www.ncwsa.com/tag/michigan-state-university/

Here are the current settings:

Cache out: Not selected
Automatically add: None selected
Location Priority: 10
Insert after: -1
Disable on mobile: Not selected
Disable on AMP: Not selected
Show meta: Selected
Limit meta to admin: Selected
Tell world: Not selected
Fetch related only from: “Same tags” selected
Taxonomy matching: Selected

Disable Contextual Matching: Selected
Disable ONLY on attachments and custom: Not selected
Number of related: 3
Related posts newer than: 365 days
Randomize: Not selected
Find related post based on content: Selected
Limit content compare: 0
Post types to include: “post” selected
Limit to same post type: Not selected

Exclude display of related: all selected

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]