Evan, I’m having the EXACT same issue as this member, i.e. ONLY ONE icon shows in the Drop down list for “Default icon.”.
At first I thought it was the Theme I was using “Optimize Press”.
However, after sending a support ticket to them, here is the response I received …
====================
“Hi Harj,
This is something we would suggest reaching out to the plugin author for as they would need to provide support for their plugin. I have checked this for you and even when the default WP theme is active it doesn’t work, so this means that OptimizePress is not causing the issue on the site.
While we would love to be able to offer support for 3rd party plugins, but it would be very difficult for us as we didn’t develop the plugin and wouldn’t be able to solve the problem unless it is being caused by OptimizePress which if it were, we would be more than glad to help further.
Please let us know if you need anything else and we’ll be happy to help
Kind Regards,
Kevin
OptimizePress Support Team
===============
Would be great to use the Pro version but right now the free one is not working for me.
Any ideas would be much appreciated because I really love this plugin.
Cheers.