Oh, I see @voodoochill, that’s a basic function of Mailchimp and how the plugin works, not really an issue per se. When your store is connected customer data comes over to your Audience for all of your customers. If you click on that user that isn’t Subscribed
they’re likely marked as Transactional
if I had to guess.
You can send those Transactional
users messages like Abandoned Carts or Order Notifications for example. If you don’t want those customers in your Audience, you could Archive them if you’d prefer.
Here in the plugin team, we don’t get into the day-to-day feature set of the Mailchimp app, but if you have more questions please reach out to their excellent customer service team via this support link. You should be able to chat with them and take things from there.
Thanks again for reaching out, let us know if there’s anything else we can do.