Plugin Not Syncing Contacts to Constant Contact

The plugin worked fine when I just used the default “e-mail” only. However, once I started creating other fields it is getting “wonky”.

I get a notification email that someone has joined the list (and it gives me the details they filled out), however the information is never getting to Constant Contact.

I have even tried creating a form with no “custom text area”, simply using the fields available in the drop down list, and even that simple it is not working.