[Plugin: Site Creation Wizard] No "Gimme a site!" option

The plugin works fine with the exception that when a new user goes to set up an account they do not have the option of “Gimme a site”. They must register then start over to get the site. I see in the forum talk about more privacy issues, yet under privacy I have selected “I would like my site to be visible to everyone, including search “.

When I turn this plugin off, the option comes back. ???

What am I missing.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/plugins/site-creation-wizard/