Quotes and spaces converts to funky characters

WordPress shows characters: “,”,‘,’ as weird code. For example, “ shows up as в??. It just recently started happening. I disabled all plugins but nothing changed. I also tried replacing the code in the database with proper html quotes and for the most part fixed it but in some random places, a big B appears before the space that is appended to the previous word. I have since changed the database back just so people can help me trouble shoot this.

Please see this page (as of 8-25-2014)
https://news.newmanu.edu/newman-university-honor-student-kristin-martin-receive-student-best-paper-award-mvhc/