Random Button not random?

This generally happens when the cache plugin that is being used cache’s the page output via the URL line, W3TC generally does this no-exception thing where the ?nocache=1 doesn’t get looked at.

Look at part 10 on this tutorial:

https://code.tutsplus.com/articles/configuring-w3-total-cache-advanced-page-cache-ii–cms-21159

You would put something like:

https://timarsenault.com/birdandmoon?random

there, test what URL works since I don’t use w3tc all I can do is guide you to the ‘exceptions’ tutorials