reCAPTCHA not showing

I was getting a ton of spam with the WP Email Capture and set up reCAPTCHA with it, providing both my site and secret keys, and putting the reCAPTCHA code in the header. However it’s not showing at all on my site.

* Note that the email form isn’t working because the spam keeps making my account exceed its limit. But my understanding is the reCAPTCHA form should be there before submitting an email.

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]