Well, I can’t rate the scope of your plugin separate from the execution, so it’s going to stay what it is. It’s a reflection of my dissatisfaction in the direction your going.
I had WooCommerce Shipping & Tax and then a popup came to try out your new shipping plugin. I tried it and it said it was going to migrate over my settings for shipping. Well, it didn’t migrate the setting because the features I use aren’t there anymore. You say it doesn’t have shipping methods but it certainly changes how shipping methods work and removes live rates function that I was using, so how is that not the same thing from the users perspective.
It also doesn’t have a place to even add weight to your shipping packages you enter as favorites. It also doesn’t migrate your previously saved shipping packages from previous pluggin. I can’t even manage to give you another star for user interface because it’s not any better. In fact it makes it more difficult to get tracking information for competed orders, so in some ways I would call it worse for user interface. You also still make me check the box to complete the order EVERY TIME I ship a package. If clicked that checkbox thousands of times.
if you want more stars, you have to solve problems. What I see is new problems and moving previously free features behind paywalls.