So far so good

It works, it works well. I’ve tried both the “big” caching/minify programs and they generally broke my site in some way. This plugin took some tweaking (I still need to find the right script to exclude Predictive Search Pro from being combined, it breaks the plugin) but overall, it not only works better, but is easier to work with. My page speed (aside from my terrible server speed) improved hugely. 79% to 94% at gtmetrix!