Hi @kjm44.
I come back to you after deeper investigation. I can confirm now, sticky post is working also on other than the front page (there has to be a change in the past in WordPress, I think).
What I did is, I created a post list and ticked the option Show sticky posts on top of the list
.
Then I created a new page and added the shortcodes as well as I added the list in the footer with the Ultimate Post List widget.
After that I created some posts with different publishing dates. For two post I ticked the option Stick to the top of the blog
.
Then I used a private browser and opened the website. The page as well as the widget in the footer show me both sticky posts at the top. Independent of the sort order I use for the list.
According to this result I assume another plugin or your theme hook into the sticky post feature from WordPress. Best way is to disable one by one other plugins and check the list.
If you have further problems, I do recommand to contact us by our contact form for Pro support and we will have a look at your WordPress installation. Please provide your license key in your message.
Otherwise I would be happy to get your short reply here to know, if you could find a solution.