Subdomain Multisite giving 404

I have my multisite setup and everything appears to be working. The main site loads just fine and I am able to create subsites and they show up in the dashboard. The problem is that when I try to access the subsite or its dashboard it gives me a 404 (not a WP themed 404).

I checked the file directory and no directory for the subsite is created at all.

I have verified that my .htaccess and config.php match -> Network Setup recommendations. I have also verified that my wildcard setup is correct in cPanel “*.website.com”.

I tried creating the subdomain manually through cPanel and then deleting and re-adding the subsite which did not work either.

What am I missing?