The plugin is adding a ‘reply-to’ email that I can’t change.

Hi @goldmaverick,

WP Mail SMTP plugin adds reply-to if you’ve checked the ‘Force From Email’ option but ‘From Email’ set by other plugin sending the email do not match the ‘From Email’ in WP Mail SMTP. In this case, the ‘From Email’ set by the plugin sending the email is added as reply-to to preserve the value. If you don’t want the reply-to, make sure the ‘From Email’ set by other plugin sending the email matches the ‘From Email’ set in WP Mail SMTP.

I hope this helps!

Hi @goldmaverick – We haven’t heard from you in about a week, so I’m going to go ahead and mark this ticket resolved. If you still have questions, though, please feel welcome to continue the conversation.