[Theme: Atahualpa] Problems with Google 1 Button

I’m not technical at all so please excuse newbie terminology

I’m using atahualpa on 2 blogs and I’ve been using wordpress for years.

I’ve tried every plugin I can find for the Google +1 button and none of them will work. When I go to a post a click on the button it turns red. Also, when I find my posts titles in the Google index, when I click the +1 button there it won’t work either.

However, it does work on one or two posts. Weird.

My blog is at https://whitehatwriting.com if that helps.

I’ve tried:
Removing FB like button
Removing FB connect button
Did a manual sitemap refresh
Got rid of Tweet This plug in
Tried several different +1 plug ins
Enabled third party cookies

Any other suggestions? I’ve searched and tried everything I could find.

https://www.ads-software.com/extend/themes/atahualpa/