Theme functionality migration

Hey, firstly thanks for reading, always impressed with the support and knowledge on offer here!

Short version: I’m migrating from a heavily modifed (and outdated) premium theme to wordpress Responsive and while trying to impliment a little but of custom functionality on a custom post. I’m trying to add a five star review to the original template but don’t quite understand how it was accomplished in the first place. Any help is greatly appreciated.

Long version: I was previously using a premium theme I had modified by some developer on Odesk ages ago but it’s so hopelessly outdated and shooting so many errors that I decided to migrate to lightly tweaked version of responsive wordpress template. I’ve been able to pull over the other customisations by and large with guides and other useful info on the forums/blogs etc but this one seems to be unique – or i just don’t know what to search for. The site uses a text input review counting 0.1-5.0 to review wine, each reviewer gives it a rating which is averaged out for an overall score. At present the site is pulling through everything but the * reviews. It’s also pushing the reviewer info across the page. Any help would be mich appreciated.

Example De Alto Wine Review

Template:

[Please post that much code to a pastebin per the forum rules – https://codex.www.ads-software.com/Forum_Welcome#Posting_Code ]