Thanks tpattle,
I found a solution by trying to fix another unrelated problem
Steps to export from old site and import to new WP site do the following:
1) in your old site in WP admin screen click Tools > Export
2) Select WP Customer Reviews and click Download Export File and save the XML file to your computer
3) Next login to your new site and click Tools> Import
4) Install WordPress once installed you see link Run Importer
5) click Run Importer and select the XML file you exported from your old site.
6) now click on Reviews and you should see all your reviews
7) Now edit each post for it to display, I changed the column “Reviewed Post” from (Not Posted) to Reviews, I think is says Reviews because that the name of the page I want to display it in. But either way it worked for me.
Hope this helps someone. If I would have know before, my last review was from 2015 and now its feb 2017.