Unable to restrict access

If I log in to my site as a “Registered User”, which should NOT allow access to any site pages EXCEPT the /user page, and I then open a new tab and manually type the URL of one of the supposedly restricted pages, the restricted page LOADS anyway. I believe I’ve set everything correctly – “Restrict access to this content?” is set for all restricted pages, with “Registered User” NOT checked. Any help most appreciated. TIA.

### Begin Install Info ###

## Please include this information when posting support requests ##

— Site Info —

Site URL: https://zealotslounge.com
Home URL: https://zealotslounge.com
Multisite: No

— Hosting Provider —

Host: DBH: mysql.zealotslounge.com, SRV: zealotslounge.com

— User Browser —

Platform: Apple
Browser Name: Safari
Browser Version: 11.1.2
User Agent String: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Ma
c OS X 10_13_6) AppleWebKit/605.
1.15 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version
/11.1.2 Safari/605.1.15

—- Current User Details —

Role: administrator

— WordPress Configurations —

Version: 4.9.8
Language: en_US
Permalink Structure: /%year%/%monthnum%/%day%/%postname%/
Active Theme: Kelly Child 1.0.0
Page On Front: Welcome (#195)
Page For Posts: EJ’s Notes (#174)
ABSPATH: /home/zealotslounge/zealotslounge.com/
All Posts/Pages: 384
WP Remote Post: wp_remote_post() works
WP_DEBUG: Disabled
WP Table Prefix: Length: 9, Status: Acceptable
Memory Limit: 40MB

— UM Configurations —

Version: 2.0.25
Upgraded From: None
Current URL Method:
Cache User Profile: Yes
Generate Slugs on Directories: Yes
Rewrite Rules: Yes
Force UTF-8 Encoding: No
JS/CSS Compression: No
Nav Menu Settings: Yes
Port Forwarding in URL: No
Exclude CSS/JS on Home: No

— UM Pages Configuration —

User: https://zealotslounge.com/user/
Account: https://zealotslounge.com/account/
Members: https://zealotslounge.com/account/
Register: https://zealotslounge.com/register/
Login: https://zealotslounge.com/
Logout: https://zealotslounge.com/logout/
Password Reset: https://zealotslounge.com/password-reset/

— UM Users Configuration —

Default New User Role: um_registered-user
Profile Permalink Base: user_login
User Display Name: full_name
Force Name to Uppercase: No
Redirect author to profile: No
Enable Members Directory: No
Use Gravatars: Yes
Gravatar builtin image: mm
UM Avatar as blank Gravatar: No
Require a strong password: Off
Editable primary email field in profile view: Off

— UM Access Configuration —

Panic Key:
Global Site Access: Site accessible to Logged In Users
Custom Redirect URL: zealotslounge.com
Exclude the following URLs:
Backend Login Screen for Guests: No
Redirect to alternative login page:
Backend Register Screen for Guests: No
Redirect to alternative register page:
Access Control widget for Admins only: No
Enable the Reset Password Limit: Yes
Reset Password Limit: 3Disable Reset Password Limit for Admins: No
Blacklist Words: 5

— UM Email Configurations —

Mail appears from: The Zealots Lounge
Mail appears from address: [email protected]
Use HTML for E-mails: Yes
Account Welcome Email: Yes
Account Activation Email: No
Pending Review Email: No
Account Approved Email: Yes
Account Rejected Email: No
Account Deactivated Email: No
Account Deleted Email: Yes
Password Reset Email: Yes
Password Changed Email: Yes

— UM Total Users —

All Users(1240)
administrator(2)
um_lifetime-member(49)
um_registered-user(1169)
um_short-term(20)
none(0)

— UM Roles —

Administrator (administrator)
Editor (editor)
Author (author)
Contributor (contributor)
Subscriber (subscriber)
Customer (customer)
Shop manager (shop_manager)
Lifetime Member (um_lifetime-member)
Registered User (um_registered-user)
Short Term (um_short-term)

— UM Custom Templates —

N/A

— UM Email HTML Templates —

N/A

— Web Server Configurations —

PHP Version: 7.0.30
MySQL Version: 5.6.34
Web Server Info: Apache

— PHP Configurations —

PHP Memory Limit: 256M
PHP Upload Max Size: 100M
PHP Post Max Size: 105M
PHP Upload Max Filesize: 100M
PHP Time Limit: 500
PHP Max Input Vars: 3000
PHP Arg Separator: &
PHP Allow URL File Open: Yes

— Web Server Extensions/Modules —

DISPLAY ERRORS: N/A
FSOCKOPEN: Your server supports fsockopen.
cURL: Your server supports cURL.
SOAP Client: Your server has the SOAP Client enabled.
SUHOSIN: Your server does not have SUHOSIN installed.
GD Library: PHP GD library is installed on your web server.
Mail: PHP mail function exist on your web server.
Exif: PHP Exif library is installed on your web server.

— Session Configurations —

Session: Disabled
Session Name: PHPSESSID
Cookie Path: /
Save Path: /tmp
Use Cookies: On
Use Only Cookies: On

— WordPress Active Plugins —

Asgaros Forum: 1.10.0
Better Search Replace: 1.3.2
DreamObjects Backups: 4.2.0
Gutenberg: 3.8.0
Invisible reCaptcha: 1.2.1
Jetpack by WordPress.com: 6.5
Joomla2WP Migrated Users Authentication Plugin: 1.0.1
MailChimp for WordPress: 4.2.5
MailChimp User Sync: 1.7.5
S3Bubble Amazon Web Services Media Streaming: 5.1
S3Media Link Safe Lite Plugin: 2.0
Ultimate Member: 2.0.25
Ultimate Member – Google reCAPTCHA: 2.0.2
WooCommerce: 3.4.5
WooCommerce Gutenberg Products Block: 1.1.2
WP-Optimize: 2.2.4
WPForms Lite: 1.4.8.1

### End Install Info ###

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]