So, I just entered my email address into the opt-in form in your sidebar and clicked the FOLLOW button.
After this, I received an email (from WordPress.com, developers of the JetPack plugin you’re using for this asking me to click a link to confirm I want to subscribe and follow your blog.
I clicked the link, which took me to a WordPress.com confirmation page that also said:
You will receive an email at [email protected] whenever a new post is made on these sites. Unfollow a blog to stop receiving emails from that blog.
So people who CONFIRM to subscribe or FOLLOW your blog are supposed to receive an email when you post new stories. Even after the confirmation, they will continue to see the FOLLOW button and opt-in form on your site.
My questions:
1) First, is this the FOLLOW you’re talking about?
2) Was the subscription confirmed?
3) If it was confirmed, is the person not receiving email notifications of new posts? (Again, the FOLLOW button on your site shows for everyone whether they are active followers or not)
Finally, kindly note that you can always contact Jetpack directly for support at https://jetpack.com/support/