User Level Restriction Messages Seemingly Inconsistent

Scenario:

I have set up simple content for each user level restriction message.

I have applied the level of “Contributor” to a post.

I have a test user with a level of “Subscriber”. But, when they visit the restricted page, instead of seeing the “Contributor” level message they receive the “Subscriber” level message.

If the test user logs out and revisits the page however, they see the correct level message.