Using with WPengine’s cache

Hi! I want to make my website visible for logged-in users only. But this only seems to work half of the time – regularly, the login screen is being skipped and the page appears to be publicly accessible. I suspect that WPengine’s built-in caching solution is interfering, and your plugin has a helpful notification that points me in that direction. I can’t deactivate their caching solution, and WPengine is a well-known managed hosting solution, who even advertise the plugin on their website (https://wpengine.com/solution-center/restricted-site-access/) – I have chatted with their support team and it is now a support ticket they are hopefully looking at, but I haven’t had much success. I can imagine there might be more people who have had this specific issue, or perhaps the plugin author might be able to offer helpful advice. Thanks!

The page I need help with: [log in to see the link]