Was perfect until…

Hello brother. The plugin is easy and effective and seems to be working among logged out and logged in users just fine EXCEPT when I am logged in via Admin.

If I am in the dashboard I have no issues but if I open the site in same browser logged in as admin I get:

There has been a critical error on this website.

I disabled and it went back to normal. I tried disabling Wordfence in case but nope. It would seem to be something simple considering it’s just admin. Point me in the right direction if you can. Was just about to leave a 5 star for simplicity but man I kinda need to see the front end lol