Hi Reilly,
It’s not possible for me to be sure what your exact problem is, as I don’t know all the ins and outs of your setup. Anyway, it’s quite possible this problem isn’t actually related to this plugin at all, seeing as the data seems to all be there, it’s could be something to do with your theme.
The first few things I would do is switch to the default wordpress theme, check to see if there is any change, and then switch back. If the default theme works as it should and your main theme still displays as it does now then it’s probably related to your theme, in which case, you’ll have to contact the theme author for support. It’s possible that just switching and switching back will fix the issue though. Sorry I couldn’t help more!
EDIT:
There are actually a lot of errors in the console on your site. Your theme stylesheet isn’t loading. I assume all of the files that make up the site have been uploaded? This plugin only handles the database not the files.
EDIT 2 — READ THIS IT MIGHT SOLVE YOUR ISSUE:
Looked again quickly, it’s adding http// after https:// of all urls it’s trying to get. When you migrated the database did you have a search replace set up similar to this?
Search: localhost/reilly/craig
Replace: http//www.reillycraig.ca
If so change it so that the http// isn’t there anymore. That might fix your problem
