Website Subscribers Having Issues with WordPress Login Page

Logging in from the homepage (UTHDynasty.com) is perfect, however, when subscribers (not my admin account however) logout and then attempt to immediately log in again from the wordpress page, it gives this message:

Oops! Google Chrome could not find https://www.uthdynasty.cominvalidpluginurlrequestedprofile

Yet if they type in the website address following this, they are logged into the site. Using the login widget I put on the homepage of the site itself does not have any issues, but the wordpress login page does. Any experience with an issue like this?
Thanks in advance!