When login is incorrect site shows admin login screen

Hi,

I am running WP 4.7.1, and version 1.5 of Login Form Anywhere. I am noticing that if I type in an incorrect username or password and submit, rather than showing the error on the current page where I have the login form, it shows the login screen like you would see when logging into the admin area. and the login form shakes like it would normally when there is an error. Is that how the plugin is supposed to work? Ideally I would like to see an error message of some sort shown on the form on the page where I am displaying it. If there is a way to get that to work with the plugin can you please assist me in setting that up?

Thanks,

Brian