WooCommerce Products Widget displaying image of wrong product

I recently took over the admin of a WooCommerce site at . As you can see on the page, at the bottom of the left sidebar I have the WooCommerce Products widget set up.

I’ve selected about a dozen products and turned on their “Featured” flag, and told the widget to display 1 product, from Featured Products, at random.

The product title and the link for it works fine and rotates randomly as expected, but it always shows the same product image – and that image isn’t even of any of the featured products.

I have tried disabling/reenabling the widget, and I’ve gone into the products in question to verify that none of them have that image associated with them.

I’m kind of at a loss. (This is my first WooCommerce site, and there’s a lot there. I’m hoping I’m just overlooking a newb kind of thing. But I’ve spent hours on it and finally decided to lean on the pros.)

Any ideas?

Marshall